Supergirl Makeup and Hair Tutorial – Cosplay Supply Link

Supergirl Makeup and Hair Tutorial – Cosplay Supply Link

supergirl cosplay

Well hello, there. Welcome to Cosplay and Coffee. My name is Tiffani and if you’re here it’s probably because you watched my YouTube Supergirl Makeup and Hair Tutorial.

If that’s the case, then you must have been impressed by my Super Skills and want to know where to get the products I used. 

If you’re looking for where to get your own Supergirl cosplay, I’ll get into that towards the end of this blog.

I’m going to keep this short and sweet for you and just list my Supergirl makeup products down below as well as some of the hair supplies I use.

RELATED: Captain Marvel Flight Suit Costume Review – Stitch’s Loft Movie Accurate Cosplay

Supergirl Makeup 


My Supergirl makeup is not meant to look exactly like Melissa Benoist. I tried to reshape my face when I did my first Supergirl video and it was sub-par and I didn’t really see a difference. 

My recommendation when doing your own Supergirl makeup is to stick to neutral colors. No blue or red or crazy comic colors (even if you aren’t doing the CW version). 

I think you can get pretty much all of these makeup products from Target except for the eyeshadow palette. If you can’t find it on the cheap, I (clearly) recommend any e.l.f eyeshadow!

I didn’t mention a lip color in my tutorial because I put on lipstick and hated it, so I just wiped it off. 

My lips are naturally a dark red, plus I lick my lips a LOT, so by the end of the day, I don’t have color on anyway. To give you some input, just go for a light pinkish lip stain or lipstick!

Supergirl makeup products I use (or mention)

    • Maybelline Fit Me! Foundation
    • e.l.f Primer
    • Kat Von D Shade + Light palette (the colors all the way to the right)
    • e.l.f Black liquid eyeliner
    • Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara, Very Black
    • Pink lip stain
    • Compact and fluffy brushes

RELATED: 16 Supergirl Cosplayers You Need In Your Life

Supergirl Hair Tutorial

I am so sorry if my tutorial seemed confusing at all. PLEASE DM me on Instagram if you have any questions. I’ll try to keep an eye out on the comments under the video as well. If I change the way I do my Supergirl hair routine at all, it will be updated in this blog!

Supergirl hair tool I use (or mention)

Supergirl Cosplay Options

CosplaySky sent me this Supergirl cosplay a few years ago. If you want to see the full review, go for it: it’s right here!

Supergirl Cosplay Review

I can’t speak as to the quality of other cosplay stores, but I do see that all the ones on Amazon right now are… not ideal.

Here are some other cosplay stores that I really like in case you want to shop around!

RELATED: 6 Best Cosplay Stores

Do you guys want me to do more cosplay transformation videos? But maybe actually do a transformation this time? I’m an amateur makeup-ist so don’t expect too much. I love learning new techniques though, so I guess if I end up creating a cosplay that I’m really proud of, I’ll share the makeup transformation!

Wow, thanks for talking me into that, you guys.

See more cosplay supply links and cosplay videos!

Supergirl Cosplay – CosplaySky Review

Supergirl Cosplay – CosplaySky Review

CosplaySky Supergirl Review

Disclaimer: Actions taken from clicking on links may yield commission for the site All content and photos are copyright Cosplay and Coffee unless otherwise noted. Sponsored content is clearly disclosed within the post. Thank you for your support and I hope these services help you!

CosplaySky is an online costume retail company that specializes in selling costumes to cosplayers. They carry garb in anything from anime to Star Wars, including props, shoes, and even wigs. CosplaySky sent me my Supergirl cosplay to review, which you can see in full on my YouTube channel: Supergirl CosplaySky Review.

For a brief breakdown, here are some highlights and low-lights for this cosplay:


  1. The top fits great, and the cape is the perfect length.
  2. It’s very comfortable and form-fitting.
  3. There is amazing attention to detail.
  4. The cape snaps right on.
  5. It shipped really fast!


  1. The velcro skirt is questionable and makes the skirt less adjustable.
  2. The shirt comes un-tucked from occasionally if the skirt isn’t tight enough.
  3. It doesn’t come with the boots.

Click here to see the full review!

If you’ve been thinking about purchasing cosplays from any other companies, but can’t find any reviews, let me know in the comments below and I’ll do some digging for you! 


CosplaySky is also giving Cosplay and Coffee viewers a 10% Discount Code! Just enter the code COSPLAYCOFFEE‘ when you checkout!


I give CosplaySky 4/5 steaming cups of coffee per our rating system for providing an excellent option for a Supergirl cosplay!

cosplay and coffee film reviewcosplay and coffee film reviewcosplay and coffee film reviewcosplay and coffee film review/5

Check out these other 16 Supergirl Cosplayers That You Need In Your Life!
16 Supergirl Cosplayers You Need In Your Life

16 Supergirl Cosplayers You Need In Your Life

16 Supergirl Cosplayers You Need In Your Life

Disclaimer: Actions taken from clicking on links may yield commission for the site All content and photos are copyright Cosplay and Coffee unless otherwise noted. Sponsored content is clearly disclosed within the post. Thank you for your support and I hope these services help you!

Supergirl first appeared in DC Comics in 1959, as Kara Zor-El in the comic titled Action Comics #252.  She also had many appearances as Superman’s cousin in a short-lived series entitled The Daring New Adventures of Supergirl in the early ’80s. It wasn’t until the late ’90s, however, that Supergirl finally starred in her own self-titled comic book series, which ran from 1996 to 2003. Now, Supergirl has become a trademark in modern pop culture thanks in large part to the CW’s television series Supergirl, starring Melissa Benoist.

This series has sparked an insane reaction among the cosplay community, and it appears that the newest televised version holds a massive inspiration for those who love the Supergirl character.  And while I love unique and traditional forms of Supergirl’s garb,  I thought it would be fun to showcase a few talented Supergirl cosplayers that have continued to represent Supergirl in the modern-day era.

So here are 16 Supergirl cosplayers that you need in your life (in no particular order):

16. Girl of Steelus

This girl takes on the complete persona of Supergirl, with her Instagram bio reading Tiah Zor-El, Aussie Supergirl. Besides her cosplay adventures, you can explore her inspiring fitness transformation and colorful days at the beach. She has also cosplayed as the Joker.

15. Aflaviaf

Ana is a cosplayer of many talents, but it’s her Supergirl cosplay that stands out. She hails from South America, making sure her love of Supergirl is shared around the world. Ana has cosplayed other characters such as Katheryn Winnick and Bucky Barnes (the Winter Soldier).

14. Onlyalicat

Aly Williams is a prominent face in the cosplay community, having indulged in a range of characters from Elizabeth Swan, Wonder Woman, and Nuka Girl. One of her most popular cosplays is Schoolgirl Ariel; a project consisting of characters in risque schoolgirl attire in the facade of popular princesses such as Ariel, Pocahontas, and Belle. Although she cosplays a lot of Disney princesses, Aly’s Supergirl cosplay is definitely top-notch. 

13. Polyjuice Cosplay

From Lavender Brown, Spider Gwen, and one impressive Rapunzel Jedi cosplay, this girl is a cosplayer on the rise! The diversity in her cosplays makes her account fun to follow, and she pulls each one off with finesse. Not to mention, her Supergirl cosplay definitely stands out among the crowd!

12. Haus_Play

Cosplay, acting, fitness, and stunts is all it takes to make you want to follow this one-of-a-kind cosplayer. Besides partaking in some pretty badass cosplay stunt videos, Erin also supplies makeup tutorials. She is another diverse cosplayer, having cosplayed characters such as Beetlejuice, Harley Quinn, and Black Widow. However, it’s pretty obvious that her Supergirl cosplay is a fan-favorite! 

11. Captain Kaycee Cosplay

Kaycee is a Nevada/California cosplayer who is a Kryptonian, Queen, Amazon, AND and Inquisitor. Yeah–try to top that. Clearly this girl possesses many talents, and her Supergirl cosplay is effortless and absolutely stunning! Supergirl is clearly one of her favorite characters, having spun out a Supergirl Jedi mashup cosplay!

10. Maid of Might

I don’t even need to tell you who this girl is. Jessica is a California cosplayer and is a shining example of a successful cosplayer. It would take half of this post to list all of the different cosplays she’s done, but some fan favorites appear to be her various Spider-suits, Captain Marvel, Anastasia, and–so so much more. Jessica has done numerous versions of Supergirl, but her modern CW Supergirl is one that she pulls off flawlessly.

9. Laney Feni

Laney Fei received extensive attention in the cosplay community for her genderbent Aquaman cosplay. She’s done just about every rendition of Supergirl you can think of, and she’s pulled off each and every one, making her a SUPERgirl cosplayer (too cheesy?). Her other notebale cosplays include Thor and Harley Quinn. 

8.  Kaylala Cosplay

While Kayla is a fantastic Disney princes cosplayer (you should see her Rapunzel), her Supergirl cosplay remains to be the best of the best. From the boots to the cape, Kayla also possesses Kara Danver’s brunette/blonde locks. Kayla seems to be a participate in just about every fandom, making her a notable cosplayer to follow!

7. Italian Supergirl

Ivana is a model and cosplayer who loves travel and adventure. Hailing all the way from Italy, Ivana is  huge advocate for the CW’s Supergirl, dedicating a majority of her posts to discussing Melissa Benoist’s role as the superhero. And, of course, Ivana’s representation of Supergirl is uncanny!

6. Supergirl_Smiles

Another Supergirl cosplayer who knows that owning just one Supergirl cosplay is not enough! You can see her dawning a Bombshell Supergirl, a festive Christmas Supergirl, and even a version of Supergirl when she’s exposed to red kryptonite! This cosplayer is always naturally smiling, giving the advice to “Be the super person you wish to see in the world!”

5. Darth Lexii

Darth Lexii is an entertaining cosplayer, especially considering her one-woman karaoke and dance videos! This actress/cosplayer from California is known for both her Supergirl and Spider-Girl cosplays, but she has an impressive cosplay ballot. It’s hard to choose just one that she portrays particularly well, but I can say that her Harley Quinn impersonation is adorable!

4. Cosplay and Coffee


It’s a-me! I’m so excited I joined the squad with the rest of these Supergirl cosplayers. This pose was surprisingly really hard to get right. 

The donut was delicious, though. Worth it. 

Want to join these Supergirl Cosplayers? Cosplay Sky has GREAT and accurate cosplays (including Supergirl) that will be a hit at any comic-con!

They have also been generous enough to give Cosplay and Coffee readers a discount to their site! Just enter COSPLAYCOFFEE when you check out!

3. Yung.Shark

Lily is a real superhero stationed in South Carolina. One of her newest cosplays to come into 2018 is a Brandon Gilbert Supergirl suit which is gorgeous and extraordinary! She routinely whips out her traditional Supergirl cosplay (Melissa Benoist style) and she wears it with ease. Lily also does a great Daku and Spider Gwen cosplay. 

2. Tiny Cat Kate

Tiny Cat Kate is a cosplayer of many talents. She’s crafty, cute, and a passionate cat lover. She has a couple of different versions of a Supergirl cosplay, but they all look fantastic on her! Kate’s Wonder Woman cosplay is another that has seen high praise from her followers, and she also does a great Daphne and Bombshell Black Canary cosplay.

1. Supergirl Diaries

Corrine Lawrence  has dedicated her cosplay career almost exclusively to Supergirl. She portrays both Helen Slater and Melissa Benoist’s versions of Supergirl (Slater coming from the 1984 Supergirl  film). Corrine is an Australian cosplayer who advocates that she is the Girl of Steel with a heart of gold.

16 Supergirl Cosplayers You Need In Your LifeWho are your favorite Supergirl cosplayers?

Get Cosplay Coupon Codes!

* indicates required

See more Cosplayer stuff!